Before life emerges, there is zero hedonic potential to be extracted from the existence of a human being. Once that life ends, it goes again to zero. This implies that during a person's lifetime, if we assume that life is a game, the function that should be maximised is the extraction of pleasure. We then need a trade-off between what is pleasure and what is gratification.
1. The kinds of ethics
Ethics is usually split by the kind of question being asked.
| Kind | Question | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Descriptive ethics | What do people in fact value and do? | "Most people act out of self-interest." |
| Normative ethics | What should a person value and do? | "You ought to maximise wellbeing." |
| Applied ethics | What should be done in this particular case? | "How much of my income should I give away?" |
| Metaethics | Is there a right answer at all, and what would make it right? | "Is any objective function correct, or only chosen?" |
Applied ethics is the usual name for what the notes call applicative ethics. Metaethics is the fourth kind, added here because the title question depends on it.
How the isms fit. Almost every ism below is a normative theory: a candidate objective function. Three of them also come in a descriptive version, and the two are easy to confuse:
- Psychological hedonism says people do seek pleasure. Ethical hedonism says they should.
- Psychological egoism says people do act for themselves. Ethical egoism says they should.
- Altruism as a fact asks whether anyone ever acts purely for another. Altruism as a duty says they should.
A descriptive claim can be tested by observation. A normative claim cannot be settled that way, which is why "people chase pleasure" does not by itself show that pleasure is what to maximise. Applied ethics is where a chosen theory meets a real decision. Metaethics asks whether choosing is all there is.
2. The isms
Two questions sort most of them: what counts as good, and whose good counts.
| Answers | Position | |
|---|---|---|
| What is good? | Hedonism | Pleasure and the absence of pain |
| Epicureanism | Tranquillity, reached by wanting less | |
| Eudaimonism (virtue ethics) | A flourishing life of good character | |
| Stoicism | Virtue alone; everything else is indifferent | |
| Whose good? | Egoism | Mine |
| Altruism | Other people's | |
| Utilitarianism | Everyone's, counted equally | |
| Is the outcome all that matters? | Consequentialism | Yes |
| Deontology | No; some acts are required or forbidden whatever follows | |
| Contractualism | What matters is what we could justify to each other | |
| Is there an answer at all? | Existentialism | None is given; each person chooses |
| Nihilism | None exists |
Named by the writer: utilitarianism, hedonism, egoism, altruism. Added: consequentialism, deontology, virtue ethics, Epicureanism, Stoicism, contractualism, existentialism, nihilism, and two narrower positions that bear on the notes, negative utilitarianism and antinatalism.
3. Each ism in brief
Utilitarianism
Definition. The right act is the one that produces the greatest total wellbeing, with every person counted equally.
Origin. Britain, 18th and 19th centuries. Francis Hutcheson gave the "greatest happiness for the greatest numbers" formula in 1725. Jeremy Bentham built the system in 1789, John Stuart Mill refined it in 1861, and Henry Sidgwick gave it its most careful form in 1874.
References. Bentham, An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation (1789). Mill, Utilitarianism (1861). Sidgwick, The Methods of Ethics (1874). SEP: The History of Utilitarianism.
Hedonism
Definition. Pleasure is the only thing good in itself, and pain the only thing bad in itself.
Origin. Ancient Greece. Aristippus of Cyrene and the Cyrenaics, 4th century BCE, prized the pleasure of the moment. Epicurus (341 to 270 BCE) argued for the calmer, lasting kind. The standard objection is Robert Nozick's experience machine (1974): if pleasure were all that mattered, plugging into a machine that supplied it would be the best life.
References. Epicurus, Letter to Menoeceus. Nozick, Anarchy, State, and Utopia (1974), ch. 3. SEP: Hedonism. IEP: Cyrenaics.
Egoism
Definition. In its descriptive form: every act is ultimately motivated by self-interest. In its normative form: each person ought to pursue their own good.
Origin. Thomas Hobbes (1651) is the usual source for the descriptive form, and Joseph Butler (1726) for the classic reply to it. Max Stirner (1844) and later Ayn Rand (1964) defended the normative form. Sidgwick treated it as one of the three serious methods of ethics.
References. Hobbes, Leviathan (1651). Butler, Fifteen Sermons (1726). Stirner, The Ego and Its Own (1844). Rand, The Virtue of Selfishness (1964). SEP: Egoism. IEP: Psychological Egoism.
Altruism
Definition. Acting for the good of another person for that person's sake.
Origin. The word was coined by Auguste Comte in France around 1851, as the opposite of egoism; his rule was to live for others. Whether pure altruism exists is an empirical question studied by C. Daniel Batson. Peter Singer's 1972 essay is the root of effective altruism, which is altruism as applied ethics.
References. Comte, Système de politique positive (1851 to 1854). Batson, The Altruism Question (1991). Singer, "Famine, Affluence, and Morality" (1972). SEP: Altruism.
Consequentialism
Definition. An act is right or wrong solely because of its outcomes. Utilitarianism and ethical egoism are both members of this family.
Origin. The idea is old; the name comes from Elizabeth Anscombe in 1958, who used it as a criticism.
References. Anscombe, "Modern Moral Philosophy" (1958). SEP: Consequentialism.
Deontology
Definition. Some acts are required or forbidden in themselves, whatever their outcomes. Duty comes before results.
Origin. Immanuel Kant, Prussia, 1785: act only on a rule you could will everyone to follow, and treat persons always as ends.
References. Kant, Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals (1785). SEP: Deontological Ethics.
Virtue ethics (eudaimonism)
Definition. The question is what kind of person to be. The aim is eudaimonia, a flourishing life, reached through good character.
Origin. Aristotle, Athens, 4th century BCE. Revived in the 20th century by Anscombe (1958) and Alasdair MacIntyre (1981).
References. Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics. MacIntyre, After Virtue (1981). SEP: Virtue Ethics.
Epicureanism
Definition. A restrained hedonism: the best life is one of tranquillity and freedom from pain, reached by limiting desires.
Origin. Epicurus, Athens, about 307 BCE. It bears directly on the split between pleasure and gratification in the notes.
References. Epicurus, Letter to Menoeceus and Principal Doctrines. SEP: Epicurus.
Stoicism
Definition. Virtue is the only good. Health, wealth and pleasure are indifferent, and peace comes from attending only to what is in one's control.
Origin. Zeno of Citium, Athens, about 300 BCE. Carried forward in Rome by Seneca, Epictetus and Marcus Aurelius.
References. Epictetus, Enchiridion. Marcus Aurelius, Meditations. SEP: Stoicism.
Contractualism
Definition. Right acts are those permitted by rules that people could agree to, or justify to one another.
Origin. Hobbes (1651) for the social contract. John Rawls (1971) and T. M. Scanlon (1998) for the modern forms.
References. Rawls, A Theory of Justice (1971). Scanlon, What We Owe to Each Other (1998). SEP: Contractualism.
Existentialism
Definition. No purpose is given in advance. Each person chooses their own and is responsible for the choice.
Origin. Søren Kierkegaard and Friedrich Nietzsche in the 19th century; Jean-Paul Sartre and Albert Camus in 1940s France.
References. Sartre, Existentialism Is a Humanism (1946). Camus, The Myth of Sisyphus (1942). SEP: Existentialism.
Nihilism
Definition. There are no objective values, so no objective function is correct.
Origin. Nietzsche diagnosed it in the 1880s as the consequence of losing religious foundations. J. L. Mackie gave the modern philosophical version, the error theory, in 1977.
References. Nietzsche, The Will to Power (notes of 1883 to 1888). Mackie, Ethics: Inventing Right and Wrong (1977). SEP: Moral Anti-Realism.
Negative utilitarianism
Definition. The aim is to minimise suffering; adding happiness matters less, or does not count.
Origin. Karl Popper, 1945. The name was given by R. N. Smart in 1958.
References. Popper, The Open Society and Its Enemies (1945). Smart, "Negative Utilitarianism" (1958).
Antinatalism
Definition. Coming into existence is a harm, so creating new people is wrong.
Origin. David Benatar, 2006, building on Arthur Schopenhauer. It starts from the same observation as the notes, that nobody is deprived of pleasure before they exist, and reaches a different conclusion.
References. Benatar, Better Never to Have Been (2006). IEP: Anti-Natalism.
One more idea, outside the isms
Satisficing. Herbert Simon (1956) argued that real agents search until an option is good enough, then stop. It questions whether a life has an objective function to maximise at all.
Reference. Simon, "Rational Choice and the Structure of the Environment" (1956).