The physical mirror always distorts the image when processed by ourselves. And then the meat mirror, being other people, are always, or at least, not as biased as how we are.
The glass mirror
A person stands against the glass and looks. The glass does its work without error: it returns the light it receives. The error comes afterwards, in the one looking.
Shown a line-up of their own face, with some versions altered to be more attractive and some less, people pick as the true one a face improved by about a fifth1. The image itself is also one that nobody else sees. A mirror reverses left and right, and people come to prefer that reversed face, while their friends prefer the unreversed one that they actually meet2. So the face a person knows best belongs to no one else's experience of them.
The same holds beyond faces. People judge themselves less prone to bias than others, and they see distortion in other minds far more readily than in their own3. The person at the glass is therefore a second mirror, made of meat, standing in front of the first, and it is the less faithful of the two.
The meat mirror
Other people reflect a person back as well. The thought is old: a sense of self is assembled from the reactions a person imagines in those around them4.
What these mirrors show well is the outside. For qualities that are strongly desirable or undesirable, such as intelligence, people who know someone well judge more accurately than that person does5. Across 263 samples and more than 44,000 people, ratings by others predicted performance at work and in study better than self-ratings did6. Inner states go the other way: a person is the better judge of their own anxiety5.
Two things limit the meat mirror. It has its own distortions: other people flatter, envy and want things. And it seldom reports. People work out how others see them mostly from how they see themselves, and very little from what others actually convey7. The reflection exists and rarely arrives.
One against the other
Set one against the other and neither wins outright. The glass, read by its owner, is the better guide to what goes on inside. Other people are the better guide to conduct, ability and effect on others, which are the things a person most wants to be right about and is least placed to see.
One meat mirror carries one person's distortions. Several that do not know each other and still agree are harder to dismiss, since their distortions are unlikely to be the same.
The practical difference is access. The glass is always there and always consulted. The meat mirror has to be asked, and the asking has to make it safe to answer.
References
Numbered in order of first citation.
- Epley, N. and Whitchurch, E. (2008) 'Mirror, mirror on the wall: enhancement in self-recognition', Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 34(9), pp. 1159-1170. doi:10.1177/0146167208318601.
- Mita, T.H., Dermer, M. and Knight, J. (1977) 'Reversed facial images and the mere-exposure hypothesis', Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 35(8), pp. 597-601.
- Pronin, E., Lin, D.Y. and Ross, L. (2002) 'The bias blind spot: perceptions of bias in self versus others', Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 28(3), pp. 369-381. doi:10.1177/0146167202286008.
- Cooley, C.H. (1902) Human Nature and the Social Order. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons.
- Vazire, S. (2010) 'Who knows what about a person? The self-other knowledge asymmetry (SOKA) model', Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 98(2), pp. 281-300.
- Connelly, B.S. and Ones, D.S. (2010) 'An other perspective on personality: meta-analytic integration of observers' accuracy and predictive validity', Psychological Bulletin, 136(6), pp. 1092-1122.
- Kenny, D.A. and DePaulo, B.M. (1993) 'Do people know how others view them? An empirical and theoretical account', Psychological Bulletin, 114(1), pp. 145-161.